By the MoveMatched editorial team · Last updated 2026-11-14
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change, so confirm with the official source or a licensed professional.
People ask whether New Jersey is cheaper than New York City for taxes. For income tax on a paycheck, the answer is usually yes once you leave the city, because New York City charges its own income tax on residents only. Property tax is a different story. This guide walks through each tax with 2026 figures from the tax agencies, plus example take home pay from our paycheck calculators.
The short answer
- Income tax: a New York City resident pays federal, New York State and New York City income tax. A New Jersey resident who works in the city pays federal and New York State tax, but no city tax.
- Sales tax: New Jersey's rate is 6.625%. The combined rate in New York City is 8.875%.
- Property tax: New Jersey towns set their own rates and the bills can be large. Check the real bill for any home before you compare.
New York City charges its own income tax
New York City residents pay a city income tax on top of New York State tax. For 2026 the city's rates run from 3.078% to 3.876% of taxable income, according to the New York State tax department's 2026 instructions.
The city tax applies to people who live in the city. The state tax department says people who do not live in the city do not pay it, even if they work there. That is the main reason take home pay goes up when a commuter moves across the Hudson.
If you live in New Jersey and work in New York
New York taxes the wages you earn in New York, so you file a New York nonresident return. New Jersey taxes its residents on all of their income, so you also file a New Jersey resident return. You do not pay both in full. New Jersey gives a credit for the tax paid to New York on the same income.
The New Jersey Division of Taxation says the credit cannot be more than the tax you would have paid if you had earned the income in New Jersey. In the examples below, New York State tax is higher than New Jersey tax on the same pay. So the credit covers the New Jersey tax on those wages, and the New York State tax is what you actually pay.
Income that New York does not tax, such as bank interest or a spouse's New Jersey wages, is still taxed by New Jersey.
Example take home pay on a $100,000 salary
These are estimates from our paycheck calculators with the 2026 tables: one job, single filer, standard deduction, no dependents, no credits and no pre tax deductions such as a retirement plan or health insurance. Your own numbers will differ.
The gap between the first two lines is about $3,441 a year. That is the New York City resident tax in this example. At a $150,000 salary the same gap is about $5,379. Try your own salary in the NYC paycheck calculator or the New Jersey paycheck calculator.
- Live and work in New York City: about $70,435 a year.
- Live in New Jersey and work in New York City: about $73,876 a year.
- Live and work in New Jersey: about $74,390 a year.
Payroll deductions are small but different
Both states take small worker contributions out of each check. They follow the state where you work, not where you live.
In New York in 2026, Paid Family Leave is 0.432% of pay, up to $411.91 a year, and the disability deduction is capped at $31.20 a year. In New Jersey in 2026, workers pay 0.425% on the first $44,800 of pay for unemployment and workforce funds, and 0.42% on the first $171,100 for disability and family leave.
Sales tax
New Jersey charges 6.625% sales tax on most goods and some services. In New York City the combined state, city and transit district rate is 8.875%.
Each state has its own list of what is taxed and what is exempt.
Property tax can change the math
If you plan to buy, do not stop at income tax. In New Jersey each town has a general tax rate per $100 of assessed value, and the bill is the assessed value times that rate. The Division of Taxation's own example is a home assessed at $150,000 with a rate of 3.758, for a bill of $5,637.
New York City taxes homes on a different system, with property classes and its own assessment rules. The two systems do not compare by rate. Compare the actual yearly tax bill on each listing, and ask the agent or the tax office for the latest one.
New Jersey has property tax relief programs for owners and renters, including ANCHOR. Our property tax relief guide explains who qualifies.
The year you move
The move year is the hard one. You are usually a part year resident of both places, and you may owe New York City tax for the months you lived in the city. Keep your lease dates, closing papers, pay stubs and W-2 forms together.
Tell your employer your new address right away so the withholding matches where you live. A tax preparer who handles both states can be worth the fee that year.
What this guide does not cover
- Yonkers has its own city income tax. It is not in these examples.
- Self employment income, stock pay, bonuses and rental income follow other rules.
- New Jersey has not published a separate rate schedule for 2026. We use the latest schedule the state has posted.
- This is general information, not tax advice.
Questions people ask
- Is New Jersey cheaper than New York City for taxes?
- For income tax on wages, usually yes, because New Jersey residents do not pay the New York City resident tax. Sales tax is lower in New Jersey too. Property tax depends on the town and the home, so compare real bills before you decide.
- Do I pay NYC tax if I live in New Jersey and work in Manhattan?
- No. The New York City income tax applies to people who live in the city. You still pay New York State tax on the wages you earn in New York.
- Do I pay income tax to both New York and New Jersey?
- You file in both states, but New Jersey gives a credit for the New York tax on the same income. The credit cannot be more than the New Jersey tax on that income.
- How much more do I take home if I move from NYC to NJ?
- In our 2026 estimate for a single filer who earns $100,000 and keeps a job in the city, about $3,441 a year. Use the paycheck calculators with your own salary.
- Is sales tax lower in New Jersey than in New York City?
- Yes. New Jersey's rate is 6.625%. The combined rate in New York City is 8.875%.
Keep going
- NYC paycheck and city tax
- NJ paycheck
- Rent affordability
- Moving from NYC to NJ: Costs, Taxes, Commute and Towns
- NJ Property Tax Relief: ANCHOR, Stay NJ and Senior Freeze
- Buyer Closing Costs in New Jersey: What to Expect
- Jersey City town guide
- Hoboken town guide
- Towns
- Find my agent
Official sources
- NY Tax Department: Form IT-2105-I (2026), state and New York City rate schedules
- NY Tax Department: nonresident questions (New York City tax applies to city residents)
- NJ Division of Taxation: income tax rate schedules
- NJ Division of Taxation: credit for income taxes paid to other jurisdictions
- NJ Division of Taxation: credit for taxes paid to other jurisdictions (GIT-3W)
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32: 2026 federal brackets and standard deduction
- NY Paid Family Leave: 2026 worker contribution
- NY Workers' Compensation Board: employee disability benefits contribution
- NJ Department of Labor: 2026 worker contribution rates
- NJ Division of Taxation: sales and use tax (6.625%)
- NYC Department of Finance: sales tax in New York City (8.875%)
- NJ Division of Taxation: general tax rates and how the bill is computed
- NJ Division of Taxation: ANCHOR program