Closter, NJ vs Tenafly, NJ
Closter and Tenafly are about 3.8 miles apart. Here is how they compare on home values, rent, how fast homes sell and the age of the housing, using the latest public data.
| Number | Closter | Tenafly |
|---|---|---|
| Typical home value | $1,201,134 | $1,322,705 |
| Typical rent | · | $4,608/mo |
| Housing units | 2,834 | 5,420 |
| Built before 1940 | 23% | 25% |
| Built since 2000 | 11% | 18% |
| County | Bergen County | Bergen County |
| School district | Closter Public Schools | Tenafly Public Schools |
- Typical home value in Closter is about 9% lower than in Tenafly.
Listing figures show asking prices, not final sale prices. Numbers describe the market, not the people who live there. Sources: Zillow (2026-09), Realtor.com (2026-10), U.S. Census Bureau ACS
About Closter, NJ

A Bergen County borough in the Northern Valley, with a compact downtown around Closter Plaza and the Closter Nature Center on its eastern side. Buses connect to the George Washington Bridge and the Port Authority. Housing is mostly single-family homes, with some townhouses and apartments.
See the Closter guide →About Tenafly, NJ

A Bergen County borough at the foot of the Palisades, home to the Tenafly Nature Center and a downtown around its old train station. NJ Transit buses run to the Port Authority and the George Washington Bridge. Housing is mostly single-family homes, with some townhouses and apartments near the downtown.
See the Tenafly guide →