Skip to content
MoveMatched

Montclair, NJ vs Nutley, NJ

Montclair and Nutley are about 2.8 miles apart. Here is how they compare on home values, rent, how fast homes sell and the age of the housing, using the latest public data.

NumberMontclairNutley
Typical home value$1,154,955$650,581
Typical rent$3,114/mo$2,347/mo
Median list price$1,199,000$659,000
Median days on market2634
Active listings5456
Listings with a price cut9%9.2%
Housing units16,52112,253
Built before 194059%31%
Built since 20009%11%
CountyEssex CountyEssex County
School districtMontclair Public SchoolsNutley Public Schools
  • Typical home value in Nutley is about 44% lower than in Montclair.
  • Typical rent is about $767 a month lower in Nutley.

Listing figures show asking prices, not final sale prices. Numbers describe the market, not the people who live there. Sources: Zillow (2026-09), Realtor.com (2026-10), U.S. Census Bureau ACS

About Montclair, NJ

An Essex County township with several downtown areas, including Church Street and Bloomfield Avenue, and the Montclair Art Museum. NJ Transit's Montclair-Boonton Line has stations across town, and DeCamp buses run to the Port Authority. Housing ranges from older single-family homes to apartments near the stations.

See the Montclair guide →

About Nutley, NJ

An Essex County township along the Passaic River and the Third River, with Franklin Avenue as its main street and Yanticaw Park in the center of town. NJ Transit buses run to Newark and the Port Authority, and Route 21 and the Garden State Parkway are nearby. Housing is mostly single-family and two-family homes, with some apartments.

See the Nutley guide →