NY and NJ news · November 5, 2026
The sixth borough math: what moving to NJ does to your take-home
NYC residents pay a city income tax that New Jersey residents do not. Here is the real take-home math by income, and what property taxes give back.
- NYC income tax top rate
- 3.876%
- gone once you are not an NYC resident
- Saved at $150,000, NY job
- $5,400
- single, state and city tax, 2025 rates
- Jersey City average property tax
- $11,249
- 2025, the part that gives it back
- NY to NJ movers, 2024
- 56,799
- 36,002 went the other way
Why people call it the sixth borough
Jersey City and Hoboken are often called New York City's sixth borough, because PATH trains put them minutes from Manhattan. The nickname is about the commute. The money is about a tax line. If you live in New York City, you pay a city income tax of up to 3.876% on top of state tax. If you live in New Jersey, you do not, even if you work in Manhattan every day. New York City has no commuter tax on New Jersey residents.
The rule most people get wrong
Moving to New Jersey does not get you out of New York State income tax if your job is in New York. You file a New York nonresident return on those wages, then a New Jersey return, and New Jersey gives you a credit for the New York tax on the same income. The credit is capped at what New Jersey would have charged on that income. In plain terms, you pay roughly whichever state's tax is higher. So for most commuters, the saving is about the same as the city tax you stop paying, and no more.
If you also move your job to New Jersey, you drop New York State tax too, and you save a bit more.
The take-home math
These are our estimates of state and city income tax only, from each state's official 2025 rate schedules. They assume wages only, the New York standard deduction, New Jersey personal exemptions, no children and no credits. Rounded to the nearest $100.
- Single, $100,000: NYC resident $8,400. NJ home, NY job $5,000, about $3,400 less. NJ home, NJ job $4,200, about $4,200 less.
- Single, $150,000: NYC resident $13,800. NJ home, NY job $8,400, about $5,400 less. NJ home, NJ job $7,400, about $6,400 less.
- Single, $250,000: NYC resident $25,300. NJ home, NY job $16,000, about $9,300 less. NJ home, NJ job $13,700, about $11,500 less.
- Couple, $150,000: NYC resident $12,300. NJ home, NY job $7,300, about $5,000 less. NJ home, NJ job $5,400, about $6,900 less.
- Couple, $250,000: NYC resident $22,900. NJ home, NY job $14,000, about $8,800 less. NJ home, NJ job $11,800, about $11,100 less.
- Couple, $400,000: NYC resident $41,000. NJ home, NY job $26,300, about $14,700 less. NJ home, NJ job $21,300, about $19,600 less.
- Couple, $750,000: NYC resident $78,500. NJ home, NY job $50,300, about $28,200 less. NJ home, NJ job $50,100, about $28,400 less.
- Couple, $1,500,000: NYC resident $158,900. NJ home, NY job $126,200, about $32,800 less. NJ home, NJ job $126,200, about $32,800 less.
How to read that table
At $150,000 single, a New York job and a New Jersey home keeps about $5,400 more a year, or about $400 a month. A couple at $250,000 keeps about $8,800.
For most people, the saving equals the full city tax, because New York State tax is the bigger of the two. That holds up to about $695,000 for a single filer and $765,000 for a couple. Above that, New Jersey's tax becomes the bigger number, since its rate climbs to 8.97% and then 10.75% while New York State stays at 6.85% until much higher incomes. A couple at $1,500,000 with New York jobs still saves about $32,800, but the city tax alone would be about $57,300.
What property taxes give back
New Jersey's average residential property tax bill was $10,570 in 2025, a record. Income tax savings do not simply go in your pocket if you buy. Compare the $5,400 above with these 2025 average bills, set against Zillow typical rents where we have them. Averages hide a lot, so get the actual tax bill for any home you are looking at.
Renters do not get a property tax bill, though it is usually built into the rent. New Jersey homeowners and renters may also qualify for a state property tax deduction or credit on their return.
- Secaucus: average tax bill $7,664, typical rent $3,058 a month
- Union City: average tax bill $8,111, typical rent $2,343 a month
- West New York: average tax bill $8,593, typical rent $2,547 a month
- North Bergen: average tax bill $8,936
- Hoboken: average tax bill $9,531, typical rent $4,005 a month
- Jersey City: average tax bill $11,249, typical rent $3,101 a month
- Bayonne: average tax bill $11,591, typical rent $2,342 a month
- Weehawken: average tax bill $14,209, typical rent $3,854 a month
- Edgewater: average tax bill $11,035, typical rent $3,628 a month
- Fort Lee: average tax bill $12,980, typical rent $3,792 a month
- Hackensack: average tax bill $10,305, typical rent $2,723 a month
- Teaneck: average tax bill $14,378, typical rent $3,297 a month
- Montclair: average tax bill $22,487, typical rent $3,114 a month
- Ridgewood: average tax bill $20,589, typical rent $4,015 a month
- Tenafly: average tax bill $25,123, typical rent $4,608 a month
Costs that do not show up on a tax form
- PATH went to $3.25 a ride on May 4, 2026, and the Port Authority plans 25 cent raises each January until it reaches $4.00 in 2029. A 30 day pass is $131.50.
- Driving into Manhattan below 60th Street costs $9 at peak under congestion pricing, on top of Hudson crossing tolls.
- Hybrid workers should be careful. New York's convenience of the employer rule can treat days you work from home in New Jersey as New York income, unless your employer requires you to work there.
Is this why people are moving?
New Jersey is the top destination for people leaving New York State. Census estimates analyzed by Cornell show 56,799 people moved from New York to New Jersey in 2024, and 36,002 moved the other way, a net of about 20,800. That data shows where people went, not why. Taxes come up often, along with rent, space and home prices, so we would not put it all on taxes.
On the tax policy side, New York's 2026-27 state budget left out the proposed income tax increase on millionaires, and added a tax on second homes in New York City. The city's 9.5% property tax increase was dropped from its budget in May, though reports say city budget gaps remain for coming years, so this is worth watching.
How to run your own numbers
- Take your New York City tax from last year's return, the line for NYC resident tax. That is about what a New Jersey move saves if you keep a New York job.
- Subtract the actual property tax on the home you want, or the rent difference.
- Add your commute cost, then compare monthly payments, not just prices.
- Ask a tax professional before you move. If you keep a New York City apartment or spend a lot of time there, you can still be treated as a resident.
One note
This is general information and not tax advice. Rates and rules change, and your numbers depend on your own income, deductions and filing status.
Keep reading
Sources
- NY Tax Department: Form IT-201 instructions (2025 rate schedules)
- NJ Division of Taxation: Form NJ-1040 instructions (2025 rate schedules, credit for tax paid elsewhere)
- NJCPA: how NJ residents avoid double taxation on NY income
- Average 2025 property taxes in all 564 NJ municipalities
- Zillow Research rent data
- Cornell Program on Applied Demographics: NY state highlights
- Time Out: PATH fare rises to $3.25
- Monaco CPA: NJ resident with a NY employer
- NYS Focus: final 2026 state budget
- Amsterdam News: NYC budget without property tax hike
- Wikipedia: Sixth borough
Rates are national averages, not offers. Home values are estimates. Nothing here is financial advice.